Insurance Agents in Shelter Island, NY

Find a home and auto insurance agent in Shelter Island, NY.

Whether you are looking to save on our homeowners or rents insurance, or you are looking to get a better rate on your car insurance policy, we have you covered. Get the best price on insurance in Shelter Island, NY from one of the insurance agents below or shop for your next policy online.

Insurance Rates Tip: All insurance companies use different rating factors to determine the cost of your insurance policy. Whether you are shopping for car insurance, homeowners or renters, or other types of insurance, get multiple free quotes from both national and local insurance companies in Shelter Island, NY to help you get the best insurance policy for your money.

Brisotti & Silkworth
Address: 50 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Description:

Offers car insurance, homeowner's, condo, renter's, watercraft, and umbrella.

Phone: 631-749-1674
State: New York
City: Shelter Island
Roy H Reeve Agency
Address: 55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Description:

Offers car insurance, homeowner's, condo, renter's, watercraft, and umbrella.

Phone: 631-749-0484
State: New York
City: Shelter Island